|I've made this scarf twice now, once with the chenille and hook that the pattern calls for and the second time with homespun and a smaller hook (P). It turned out really nice both times. I gave the chenille one to my sister and people kept asking her where she bought it! :) The homespun one was really heavy though, so I think sticking to the large hook is important. It was really simple and fun to make, I recommend it!